Gamification is about motivation Permalink
Michael Lopp defending gamification:
... there are a lot of folks who think gamification means pulling the worst aspects out of games and shoving them into an application. Itâ€™s not. Donâ€™t think of gamification as anything other than clever strategies to motivate someone to learn so they can have fun being productive.
Gamification is a buzz word, and it's gotten a bad name. Brent Simmons calls it manipulative, and Ben Brooks is a bit more colorful (and passionate).
The ever-insightful Lukas Mathis took the thoughtful middle ground. After I read his piece, I started a draft of my own. Now that draft will probably never see the light because, although the whole article is worth reading, Lopp has in three sentences summed up my feelings.
Of course, if your purpose in using gamification is anything other than helping the user enjoy learning and to be productive, then you'd do well to hear from the critics how you might be making your users feel about your software.